Do you feel Jewish? Are you Jewish at heart?
Often when I encourage someone to do an extra mitzvah, I’ll get one of two responses. Either they’ll say to me, “I’m Jewish at heart, isn’t that what G-d wants from me?” or I’ll get the “I don’t want to be a hypocrite” response.
What’s interesting is that both of these responses are so non-Jewish! Judaism places extremely high value on action-oriented mitzvahs. To the extent that if one would do the motions of a mitzvah with no intent and meaning, they have fulfilled their obligation; whereas if one would have all the correct intentions, meditate for extended periods of time, but omit the actual deed, they have not fulfilled their obligation.
In other words, if you're only Jewish at heart, that’s not really the Jewish way at all!
Taking that a step further, if you profess not to believe but do the mitzvah anyway, that’s not hypocritical – the mitzvah is still a valid mitzvah!
Which reminds me of the story of the Alter Rebbe, the first Chabad Rebbe, who was once told that a certain follower of his was not completely honest about his behavior and displayed a higher level of piety around certain crowds than he was known to follow in private.
The Rebbe responded, “May his end be what the Talmud prescribes about such people.”
That sounded ominous. The tattler suddenly felt perhaps he had overstepped a little, and tried to minimize his previous report.
The Alter Rebbe explained that the Talmud writes about someone who fakes an illness, that he won’t die until he suffers from the illness that he had faked. “May this occur to him too, let him soon actually attain the level of piety that he professes to maintain.”
So don’t just be Jewish at heart – be Jewish outwardly too. And if you think that may be hypocritical, it won’t be long until you’re affected by your actions.

